This will probably be one of the toughest posts I've ever written on this blog. why? Because it took me a long time to stop blaming myself. I don't know if it was from how society acts about breastfeeding, from the expectations of my family, or the expectations of myself.
Sophie was hours old when I faced the second biggest challenge in my life: nursing . Giving birth and having a baby was first. I was doomed from the start, my milk hadn't come in, and Sophie refused to nurse, she had no interest in it at all. the few minutes of no interest moved to an hour, and finally a nurse came in. We'll call her Sally.* She was nice, clearly an older, more experienced nurse and she showed me how I should be nursing, but nothing. Either my body wasn't working for Sophie or Sophie didn't like the nipple. Looking back, I should have known that I was not destined for breastfeeding instead of blaming myself for months on end.
The same nurse told me gently, "She needs to eat, it's been three hours, and babies this young should be eating frequently. We can try formula?" Formula? I thought, I had nothing against formula, but coming from a line of successful breastfeeders, I already felt like a failure as a mother.
And so it begin, the entire time I was in the hospital Sophie loved her the bottle, but refused the nipple. Sally suggested so that Sophie could at least receive breastmilk, which to her, it was obvious that I wanted Sophie to have, I could pump. Pumping was the third biggest challenge, the one thousand parts and feeling like a cow getting milked didn't help my ego at all. The only thing that made me feel better was that Sophie was drinking some of my breastmilk.
Problem was I was only producing maybe 8oz a day, despite the gazillion times I pumped and pumped and pumped, most sessions I ended up empty handed. It started quietly, and almost slipped by, but in the back of my mind it grew, guilt.
Guilt for having to supplement.
Guilt for not being able to breastfeed.
Guilt for hardly producing .
Guilt for being the only one in my family who couldn't breastfeed.
It began to eat away at me, slowly but surely. Each day came with more sadness that I couldn't breastfeed and that as Sophie's appetite grew so did the supplementation. I think a part of me knew that from the very beginning I wouldn't be able to really breastfeed but the very fact that I tried should in itself should be a triumph. But I didn't see it as one. In fact, everyday became a mind struggle: was it worth crying everyday because I wasn't producing enough or because I had to feed my child formula because this wonderful body that carried her just couldn't produce?
The beginning of the end was when my supply dried up in one breast and the other one became so impacted that it never cleared, meaning I wasn't producing any milk at all. I couldn't produce out of my right side at all and the left never cleared. I tried for a whole week, but no luck.
At this time I really thought over and over and over again if this was a sign that giving my daughter formula wasn't such a bad thing and that it was okay to stop breastfeeding. I had struggled from the beginning on giving her formula and not being able to produce as much milk as other moms around me. It took me months to forgive myself, and several months after that to stop beating myself up and a few more months to be okay with my decision of moving to formula only when Sophie was a month old.
See this girl in the picture above? I want to tell her it was okay to stop completely at the one month mark. And that the beautiful nearly 17 month old child we have shows that. And to stop beating herself up for not breastfeeding her child for the recommended year. there's nothing wrong with formula, but I had grown up thinking that formula was only for "non real" moms. That's obviously not true, but somewhere along the line I had picked that up and it stayed in my head for nearly a year.
I used to think it was the pressures of society, and while I still think that society has a major influence, I think most of the pressure of breastfeeding came from myself. I had these intensely high expectations of myself, and when I failed those expectations I couldn't let it go. I didn't feel like a super mom, I felt like an ordinary mom, but it's clear from how Sophie acts that I'm her super mom and breastfed or formula fed I think what really matters is what my daughter thinks.
credit
*for the protection of the nurse, her name won't be revealed.
linking up with:
i should be mopping the floor
,
the life of the faith
,
the quinntess
ential mommy
,
Smart Party Planning
,
a life in balance
,
lipgloss and crayons
,
huckleberry love
,
karens up on the hill
,
healthy diva eats
,
a mama's story
,
she lives free
,
life of meg
,
my joy filled life
,
ember grey
,
the modest mom
I understand completely friend! Harper never was interested in breastfeeding despite how much I tried. Sadly, our hospital made me feel horrible that I couldn't breastfeed instead of trying to help me and Harper but I'm glad you had a nurse who was willing to reassure you that formula would be okay. For months, I was so ashamed to admit to other mama friends that we weren't able to breastfeed. But it's nice to know that there are other mamas out there who didn't and who felt the same mom guilt as I did!
Reply DeleteVisiting from the link up! Good for you for sharing your story! I'm not a mom yet but I hope to be someday and honestly the biggest thing that scares me about motherhood is the "Mommy Wars" and the guilt/pressure to live up to my expectations and the expectations of everyone else. Your daughter is beautiful and is lucky to have a mama who clearly cares so much about her! Hope you have a fantastic week! :)
Reply DeleteThank you so much for your honesty... It's amazing the amount of guilt that pops up the second we become mothers - from breastfeeding, to birth, to who knows what else! The instant appearance of mommy guilt sure surprised me after our first was born.
Reply DeleteYou and your daughter are beautiful! Know that you are a wonderful mom! It's clear that you are doing the absolute best you can for your baby!
Amy @ http://www.livinglifetruth.com/
Too true, thank you for your words, I hope you come back and check since you're a no reply blogger. I think mommy guilt is so normal because motherhood is such an unknown for all of us. there is not method or science that proves which is the best type of motherhood. Of course we learn from what we're told or heard, which is where I got this idea that I wasn't a good mother because I gave her formula.
DeleteNo matter what we do as moms, someone in society will argue against it and make us second guess ourselves. I finally learned that I just had to do what was right for my own kiddo, and not compare to what others I knew were doing. (I'm relearning that again with number 2...that old comparison and guilt thing doesn't seem to go away easily). If you love your child and treat them well, that is all that matters!!
Reply DeleteSo brave of you to share your struggles. I truly think that just as we are told to take birthing classes, a visit with a lactation consultant/breastfeeding classes before birth should be a bigger part of our culture as well, so we don't go in completely blindly, not knowing what the heck to expect. Your daughter has grown up so much and seems like a super happy healthy child. That to me means a job well done, mama!
Reply DeleteI had so. much. trouble. breastfeeding too. Sometimes it's hard to think about, because the newborn days were so filled with depression over feeling like a failure. I really appreciated this piece.
Reply Delete-Erin (No Bohns About It)
Hi Erin, hope you come back and check since you're a no reply blogger. I remember there being days that I just cried and cried because it was just so incredibly tough for me in the first few weeks. After I stopped being so hard on myself it got easier. We're both great mothers regardless of breastfeeding or not :)
DeleteUgh, this just makes my stomach hurt when I hear stories like this...you are an AMAZING mama. You are amazing because of the love you have for your baby, and how hard you tried to make something work. Do you know how lucky your baby was to receive any breastmilk??!! I work with mamas trying to breastfeed, and it makes me so sad when they come down so hard on themselves. breastfeeding or not, doesn't make you a mother. The love and support does. :)
Reply DeleteThank you Cara! Your words mean a lot. I think I've always been tougher on myself than necessary because I expect this different outcome and when it came down to it, I wanted to enjoy breastfeeding and be able to do it, and neither happened so I think it was just harder for me to accept that at first. Also I can't seem to reply to you via email.
DeleteHope you have a wonderful week!
Oh sweet mama, I'm so sorry it was such a struggle and you felt such guilt. I'm not a mommy [yet, hope to be one day in the future] but I've heard so much about mommy guilt and it makes me so sad. One of my best friends struggled with breast feeding and had to do formula and while she was fine with it other mommies made her feel bad about it. Why how someone else lives their life with their child is anyone else's business is beyond me [unless someone is being hurt or abused etc]. I think you did what you needed to do AND THAT IS WONDERFUL! You have a beautiful daughter and that is what matters :)!
Reply DeleteNew Follower from Mingle Monday! I love finding other Mommy blogs! I really enjoyed this post!! Thank you!
Reply DeleteXOXO
Joanna
Always glad to find new friends! Glad you liked this post, hope you come back and check this comment since you're a no reply blogger
DeleteHey, very nice site. I came across this on Google, and I am stoked that I did. I will definitely be coming back here more often. Wish I could add to the conversation and bring a bit more to the table, but am just taking in as much info as I can at the moment. Thanks for sharing.
Reply DeleteTransport Wheelchair
Keep Posting:)
Thank you for your kind words, hope you come back and check since you're a no-reply blogger. Have a great weekend.
DeleteBless your heart! I decided early on in my pregnancy that breastfeeding wasn't for me. I've had some people try to shame me into breastfeeding and others praise me for my decisions. In the end, you have to do what's best for you and baby! :)
Reply DeleteMy mom is a lactation consultant and a OB nurse who works daily with women who breastfeed. I had the toughest probably 3 months, it finally got easy and then around the 9 month mark my baby just completely self weaned. Wanted nothing to do with the breast. I started him on formula. If it wasn't for my mother i would have probably switched to formula a long time ago. Giving your child breast milk or formula makes you no less then a mother than I am. I enjoyed reading this!
Reply DeleteOh, mama! I know how you feel! I tried so hard to nurse my first born. It lasted three (very long!) months and finally I gave up. I was miserable. But, I think I went in to it thinking it was going to be easy and, boy, was I wrong. But, if you have another child, try breastfeeding again. My second and third time around was much, much easier. But, it's absolutely ok if you don't. We each have to make decisions for our family that only we can make. Thank you for sharing your heart and for linking up with Waiting on...Wednesday
Reply DeleteHolly @ www.iwillservewhileiwait.blogspot.com
Liz, everyone is going to tell you what to do, what you should do, and if what happens if you don't. IN EVERYTHING. You did the right thing. Feeding your baby is the number one priority no matter how it gets done. I am a big advocate of breastfeeding, but with that said, it is NOT for everyone, no matter what the circumstances are. My daughter did if for the full first year with her first, and she was miserable. The second one came, she did it for the first 6 weeks, still miserable and we encourged her to give it up and put that baby on formula. A mother "as a whole" needs to be happy, healthy and available for her baby. Proud of you my friend. A hard and heartwrenching decision to make I'm sure.
Reply DeleteThank you so much for sharing your struggles! There are many other mothers who have experienced similar situations. Thanks for sharing at Grandma Ideas Sharing Time link up!
Reply DeleteHi Nina, you're a no-reply blogger, so I hope you come back and check, thank you for your kind words! I hope you have a great week!
DeleteMom guilt is a ugly beast! It never ends...even when they are almost adults! Keep your chin up, you have a beautiful and healthy daughter!
Reply DeleteHi Briana! Thank you for your thoughtful post, I am very lucky to have a healthy daughter. I hope you have a wonderful day!
DeleteHello Liz, great post. :)
Reply DeleteI also come from a family that we always breastfed. Formula wasn't an option for me. And then I faced reality. And the guilt, the feeling of being a fail mother and the tears and the terrible physical pain every time I breastfed. I ended up using both breast and formula. And I felt ashamed for it.
I did breastfeed BUT, that was because I got really, really lucky. On the 1st month appointment, the doctor asked me to breastfeed (an action I hated with all my heart because of the excruciating pain). And she found out two things:
- My baby was a poor latcher. Not me, the baby. She just couldn't get it right, no matter how I distorted and twisted my breasts to help her. Many babies are simply not talented in breastfeeding and it is not the mother's fault. I know a woman (with large breasts and a lot of supply) who breastfed perfectly her firstborn but, the second child just failed. The child's *fault*; not the mother's. He kept latching poorly, he bit her so much they stitched her nipples. She fought the pain for a few months and then gave up. She was an experienced breastfeeder, with huge supply, and yet it didn't work with her second child.
- I didn't just have supply, my supply was coming up so fast, the baby had trouble and was choking from too much milk. The doctor showed me how to PAUSE the flow. Who would have though? I had no idea that was possible, I though babies are natural feeders and the only problems are when a mom has low supply.
Not true.
No mother that tried should blame herself. Some babies simply fail, no matter what techniques we try.
Also, my previous lactation consultants had been clueless. Their help was pitifully inadequate. I simply got lucky a whole month later finding the one person who really knew how to help. If you ever get pregnant again and want to try breastfeeding, keep in mind that maybe:
- you get lucky and get an good latcher
if not:
- you may have too fast flow too
- your baby may be a bad feeder
- you didn't get lucky to find a good consultant
If I were to compare myself to you, me eventually breastfeeding and you not, our only difference is I merely got lucky to get the right advice. You tried and that makes you a beautiful mother.
Thank you for your great post, sorry if my response is too long, I just wanted to give you examples on occasions it is not be the mother's "fault" or "fail". And it definitely is not a shame that you gave formula. You are raising a beautiful daughter. :)
Your response is definitely not too long! I really do hope you come back and check since you're a no reply blogger, but it means a lot of me what you said. I did find it hard to breastfeed, but looking back at it I am incredibly glad I at least tried. That was the most important to me. Thank you so much for writing such a nice response. I'm sure I'm not the only one out there that could use this advice.
DeleteHappy Wednesday!